| F39127/FUL/KO
Conversion of dwelling into 3 self contained dwellings (as amended by
plans received 22/6/04 and 9/07/04)
An amendment had been received for a proposed porch and alterations to
fenestration to include new roof lights.
The Clerk noted that Cllr Carryer had declared a personal and prejudicial
interest in this application.
Kingsley Parish Council has no objection to this planning application
.
F30633/013/FUL/SR
and F30633/014/LBC/SR Alterations/extension to cellar, conservatory to
side and external staircase (revised scheme to 30633/008/LBC) at Grooms
Farm, Frith End Rd, Frith End
Kingsley Parish Council has no objection to this planning application.
FF20864/007/FUL/KO
Two detached bungalows with integral garages and associated access after
demolition of outbuildings at Southview, Main Rd, Kingsley
1. OVERVIEW
Kingsley Parish Council OBJECTS to the above application despite the fact
that this latest application is a far more modest proposal. Despite the
applicant's statement we do not feel it resolves the main issues of any
proposal on this site which are:- a. The character of this area of Kingsley.
b. The setting of an adjacent Grade II listed building. c. The Amenities
of the occupiers of the houses in the immediate vicinity.
2. THE CHARACTER OF THIS AREA OF KINGSLEY
To quote the Appeal Decision dated 16 January 2006:- "While the dwellings
are variously set back in their plots it seems to me that they do observe
a broad consistency of alignment in their relationship with Main Road
and on occasions permit glimpses through gaps towards the countryside
surrounds. While I accept that there are some deeply set buildings at
Sandyfields Farm, their backland situation as a farm complex can reasonably
be perceived to compromise a different context from the dwellings that
extend along the road. In that regard there are no dwellings to the rearward
of the frontage properties. While I note that there are some low key buildings
at the back of the dwellings including a timber building in a corner of
the site, these structures are of little visual significance in terms
of the character of the locality. In that regard, I consider that the
deep gardens to the properties notably the open qualities of those at
South View, Westerkirk House and the Old Rectory contribute significantly
to the rural setting of the village where it adjoins the bordering countryside
hereabouts. Being located rearwards of the existing dwelling running along
Main Road the new building would be markedly at odds with the established
pattern of dwellings which characterise this locality". In our view, in
achieving the two dwellings proposed the resulting building would be visually
intrusive in extending across virtually the width of the site thus materially
impacting in the rural setting which would be significantly diminished
by its large presence at the village margin. Therefore the proposal would
not be compatible with the character and visual qualities of the area
and would accordingly conflict with the aims of policies GS5 and HE2 respectively
in the adopted and emerging Local Plans.
3. THE SETTING OF AN ADJACENT GRADE II LISTED BUILDING (WESTERKIRK HOUSE)
One of the proposed buildings will be very close to the boundary with
Westerkirk House and would therefore be materially damaging to the setting
of this listed building and so be in conflict with the relevant policies
(ENV19 & HE12).
4. THE AMENITIES OF THE OCCUPIERS OF THE HOUSES IN THE IMMEDIATE VICINITY
(WESTERKIRK HOUSE, THE SPINDLE, DEAN COTTAGES & SANDYFIELDS FARM)
There will be some loss of amenity to all the above properties with an
increase in noise, dust and pollution. There will be some overlooking
and loss of privacy in gardens.
5. OTHER ISSUES
a. Flooding . We have been presented with photographic evidence of flooding
in the gardens of Dean Cottages & Sandyfield Farm on 20 July 2007. The
relevance of this is difficult to gauge but in view of recent weather
and despite in the past the Environment Agency stating there is no problem
we feel it might be prudent to re-check the causes.
b. Sustainability. How sustainable is the village of Kingsley is a debatable
question. Certainly it has limited amenities and the need for a car is
almost essential.
F39854/002/FUL/CM Driveway and vehicular access at 1 Main Rd, Kingsley
Kingsley Parish Council trusts that this second application, with several
alterations, now meets with the Highways Officer's approval as the humanitarian
needs of this family are of great importance with a severely disabled
son. Kingsley Parish Council supports this application and very much hopes
that the planning officers can find a way to accommodate the needs of
this family Cllr Neville advised Councillors that this application was
due to be considered as a Section II item at the EHDC North Planning meeting
on Thursday this week. The planning department's recommendation was refusal,
although now only on the grounds of inadequate visibility.
Cllr Neville
said that he felt this was inconsistent with the same Highways Officer's
lack of concern over visibility when the battle over Dennards' expansion
plans had been fought 7-8 years ago and he felt it was illogical to refuse
this application which would not change the existing visibility one way
or the other. He had spoken to the planning officer and e-mailed Cllr
Patrick Burridge and asked Cllr Comber to support the application at the
planning meeting.
|